| Venue | Year | Horse's Name | Winning Owner |
| Calgary | 1985 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Westlock, Alberta |
| Trem-Y-Wyddfa Jeanette | Blake & Fran Anderson, Cochrane, Alberta |
| Calgary | 1986 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Westlock, Alberta |
| Country Roses Felicia | Brett Howell, Blackfoot, Idaho |
| Calgary | 1987 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Westlock, Alberta |
| Bigfoot Fantasia | Arlin Wareing, Blackfoot, Idaho |
| Calgary | 1988 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Westlock, Alberta |
| Fordon Sarah | Blake & Fran Anderson, Ponoka, Alberta |
| Calgary | 1989 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Westlock, Alberta |
| Trem-Y-Wyddfa Jeanette | Blake & Fran Anderson, Ponoka, Alberta |
| Toronto | 1990 | Swallow Hill Sir Andrew | John & Judy McNish, Newbury, Ohio |
| Bosley Minns Gillian | John & Judy McNish, Newbury, Ohio |
| Toronto | 1991 | Grayingham Lucky Lad | Keith Gibson, Alberta |
| Gentle Giant Lucky Choice | Keith Gibson, Alberta |
| Toronto | 1992 | Walton Troop Leader | Randy & Peggy Chapman, Blackstock, Ontario |
| Millbank Countess | Randy & Peggy Chapman, Blackstock, Ontario |
| Toronto | 1993 | Walton Troop Leader | Randy & Peggy Chapman, Blackstock, Ontario |
| Gentle Giant Lucky Choice | Keith Gibson, Alberta |
| Toronto | 1994 | Bodernog Crusader | Dennis & Joan Woodhead, Plainfield, Ontario |
| Whitefeather Lady Di | Karla Leum Stoner, Frederick, Maryland |
| Calgary | 1995 | Tremoelgoch Gold Award | Keith Gibson, Alberta |
| Gentle Giant Lucky Choice | Keith Gibson, Alberta |
| Toronto | 1996 | Bodernog Crusader | Dennis & Joan Woodhead, Plainfield, Ontario |
| Millbank Countess | Randy & Peggy Chapman, Oakwood, Ontario |
| Calgary | 1997 | Tremoelgoch Gold Award | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Gladwin Gold Jayna | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Toronto | 1998 | Metheringham Upton Isaac | Gene & Vicky McCaffrey, Schoharie, New York |
| Seven Pines Lady Margaret | Randy & Peggy Chapman, Oakwood, Ontario |
| Calgary | 1999 | Deighton Noel | Rob Glenn, Strathmore, Alberta |
| Argonaut's Kali | Frank Pfannenstiel, Powell, Wyoming |
| Toronto | 2000 | Metheringham Upton Isaac | Gene & Vicky McCaffrey, Schoharie, New York |
| Hideaway Pond Coppelia | Ron & Lisa Young, Lebanon, New York |
| Calgary | 2001 | Hillmoor Double Diamond | Arlin Wareing, Blackfoot, Idaho |
| Acle Betty | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Carp | 2002 | Tremoelgoch Courage | Derek Mitcham, Yorkshire, England |
| Acle Betty | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Calgary | 2003 | Fox Valley Fame | Blake & Fran Anderson, Didsbury, Alberta |
| Gladwin Gold Jayna | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Calgary | 2004 | Hillmoor Double Diamond | Arlin Wareing, Blackfoot, Idaho |
| Gladwin Gold Jayna | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Calgary | 2005 | Ruskington Danny | Frank Pfannenstiel, Powell, Wyoming |
| Heart Mt. Pippen's Posy | Frank Pfannenstiel, Powell, Wyoming |
| Calgary | 2006 | Gladwin Courage's Danny | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |
| Gladwin Jubilee Reign | Keith Gibson, Dapp, Alberta |